“Increasingly disconnected from the "adult" world of tradition, culture, history, context and the ability to sit down for more than five minutes with a book…”
“Writing off any generation before it’s 30 is what’s dumb.”
The two quotes above came from separate articles. However, it wasn’t until I looked at both together that my thoughts began to stumble. I think it’s probably important to note, first, that I did agree with a lot of what both articles talked about. In fact, I think it would be nearly impossible for anyone to disagree with the facts and truth put forward in both articles, and by Mark Bauerlein alike. Yet, I’m not really the type of person that likes to sit back when someone is criticizing me, my friends, or in this case, even my entire generation for that matter. So, I couldn’t help but agree and be understanding of what facts the articles presented about our generation, but this doesn’t mean I’m just going to lie down and take what they have to say. I think we, as part of what is all but officially being termed the dumbest generation, have some “room to talk” this time.
I just want to start by mentioning how the word “tradition” from the first quotation really bothers me. It mentions how we are seemingly “disconnected from the ‘adult’ world of tradition.” Why does this necessarily make us in some way or another, a weaker generation? Just because we aren’t following tradition, we aren’t “going with the flow”, doesn’t me that we should be any less credited for what we ARE doing; or at least in my opinion. Sure, we may lack knowledge in some areas, those “traditional” areas, but we more than make up for it in others; others that may seem not as efficient now, but that may end up engineering “an affordable 100mpg car”, or “discovering the difference in the genetic fingerprints of cancers that spread and those that do not...” Both of which would involve technology, the source that has supposedly been the source for this “dumber” generation.
Next, I just want to point out that, yes, we are a different generation in many ways, but who’s to say that this makes us any better or worse? By attacking our knowledge the way that Bauerlein seems to be doing in his book, he is doing nothing less than attacking us for not living up to expectations. Yes, we are a different generation, full of technology and sorts, but the generation before us was different from the one that preceded them as well. I’m quite positive that the generation that came before us didn’t know as much about, for example: nature, than did the generation that came before them! Sure, our generation may be “dumber” in some aspects, but we’re also more intelligent in others.
“Writing off any generation before it’s 30 is what’s dumb.” When a group of kids who knows nothing about, for example, politics now develops the cure for cancer in 5 or 10 years will critics, and Bauerlein alike, still question our knowledge as a generation?
In this ad, Barack Obama preaches about “change”. He mentions how change is needed. Granted, while he is talking about our economy and health insurance, we are talking about the actions of an entire generation. My point being, however, that maybe change is a good thing in this case too. Just think, the generations preceding ours weren’t exactly perfect after all! Similarly, our economy isn’t exactly perfect right now either. Change could be the answer in both scenarios. Who knows, maybe we do know a little about politics after all…
"Yes, we are a different generation, full of technology and sorts, but the generation before us was different from the one that preceded them as well...Sure, our generation may be “dumber” in some aspects, but we’re also more intelligent in others."
ReplyDeleteI couldn't have said it any better. Your quote proves the point that we're all trying to make. For Bauerlein to say that we are the dumbest generation it just means he is overlooking the advances that we are capable to make. Our country needs change, and I believe our generation is going to make the changes that we need to see.
"By attacking our knowledge the way that Bauerlein seems to be doing in his book, he is doing nothing less than attacking us for not living up to expectations."
ReplyDeleteI really liked when you said this. There are many so called "expectations" in this world that young people are age are "supposed" to try to live up to. Who makes these "expectations" anyways huh? Why are we "expected" to be a certain way, live a certain life, attain a certain amount of knowledge? Life shouldn't just be about living up to expectations. I feel that our generation is expected to know everything there is to know about anything and everything which is surely impossible.
I agree with you in that our generation does know more about other things than the generation before us, and the generation after us will probably know more about other things than we do.
Life is always changing, evolving, mutating itself..there will always be something new or different in the future.
I have seen this aspect in my own and a lot of what I have read in other blogs about how no light is being shined on the advancements we have made and are continuing to make. We are being belittled by those who may not have accomplished much themselves in there "ever so great generation". Is that fair? It's as if they are saying "we didn't do much, so now you and your generation have to make up for it". Did anybody put such high expectations on the generation before us? I doubt it. So why does that change now?
ReplyDeleteI love the conversation that's happening in your group!
ReplyDeleteI love love love how you mention "will people still critize when we find a cure for cancer?" That makes me SOOOO happy! It is definitely true that even after all of the advancements we have made people STILL point the finger at us. I agree that all of us agree that we need recognition for what we know rather than what we do not. We have come so far from what people considered "impossible" with technology that it is almost scary exciting what we will be able to do in years to come. I also believe that no matter how hard we fight for recognition that the criticism will never end.. my own grandma asked me for help when reading her email.. then when I showed her replied with "wow, how long did it take you to figure that out? I bet you could have read a book in that time." ... Thanks grands ;)
ReplyDelete